Back to all blog posts

Court Rules: Google Has an Illegal Grip on the Search Market

By Asaf Shamly | September 10, 2024

Google has a major problem on its hands. A judge just ruled that the tech giant has an illegal grip on the search market. As if the judge’s siding with the Department of Justice (DOJ) isn’t bad enough for Google, some of the evidence against the trust came from where nobody expected, its own witnesses in the trial.

We’re talking about some juicy stuff here. Google’s own witnesses such as Jerry Dischler – their former VP and GM of ads – casually admitted to raising search ad prices without telling advertisers. But wait, there’s more. Get this: another Google witness spilled the beans on the trust’s ties with Safari. Apparently, Google pays Apple a 36% revenue share to be Safari’s default search engine. Evidence pages in their hundreds prove one thing. Google’s search monopoly is big. What hits even harder is the expected impact the revelation has in the real world.

 

So what happens next?

The exact sanctions Google faces are unclear, as there’s still room for an appeal. For sure though, Google’s definitely in hot water. When it comes to possible outcomes of the revelations, a full break-up of Google is a bit too drastic. Even breaking up Google’s search monopoly is going to be a tough nut to crack. The court might still impose some serious changes to their operations. Maybe the judge will limit the contracts that allow Google to remain on top. Selling some parts of Google is also feasible.

If the court decides to make Google sell one part of the business like Chrome or Android, that would be crazy! But, it might tell where we are going regarding the other upcoming trial and if they will make them split Google Ad Manager from Google Ads.

 

It’s not over yet

Just when you thought things couldn’t get any worse for Google, there’s a new antitrust trial starting September 9th. This time, the DOJ accuses Google of monopolizing digital advertising.

With a proven monopolist on trial, the DOJ’s job got a lot easier.

One last thing, the September antitrust trial is believed to put Google in front of even tougher sanctions. The judge already stated there are not going to be any concessions this time, particularly on accusations such as deleting evidence, something Google encouraged its employees to do. Google’s luck might be running out.

 

Latest Articles

  • Why Bad News Gets Clicks (But Doesn’t Always Pay)

    We’re naturally drawn to bad news but when it comes to ad dollars, it’s not always so straightforward. Read this article to explore why bad news gets clicks but doesn’t always pay and what really impacts engagement and ad revenue.

    View Now
  • Why Perplexity AI’s Approach Might Be Its Downfall in the Battle with News Corp

    News Corp is accusing Perplexity of using its articles to fuel search results without permission in a move that crosses copyright red lines. In other words, News Corp is saying Perplexity is taking advantage of news content without contributing anything back. This type of accusation isn’t the first and probably not the last in the gray area of AI.

    View Now
  • The Open Internet and Direct Deals are Making a Quiet Comeback

    Since 2021, open programmatic ad spending has barely grown by 3% while the walled gardens - think Google and Amazon - have surged ahead with 10% growth. This gap raises questions about the future of the open internet. But, against this data, there are signs this landscape may become more balanced.

    View Now